----- Original Message 
-----
From: Muhammad Zahid Inam
From: DR KHALID SHOUQ pakissan2002@yahoo.com
Story of resignation of CEO Punjab Agriculture & Meat Company (PAMCO)
(Outsourcing Operations & Management of Lahore Meat Processing Complex)
Punjab Agriculture & Meat Company (formerly known as Lahore Meat Company) is Govt of the Punjab owned not for Profit Organization registered under Section 42, Company Ordinance 1984.
From: Muhammad Zahid Inam
From: DR KHALID SHOUQ pakissan2002@yahoo.com
Story of resignation of CEO Punjab Agriculture & Meat Company (PAMCO)
(Outsourcing Operations & Management of Lahore Meat Processing Complex)
Punjab Agriculture & Meat Company (formerly known as Lahore Meat Company) is Govt of the Punjab owned not for Profit Organization registered under Section 42, Company Ordinance 1984.
Lahore Meat Processing 
Complex (modernized slaughtering & processing facility) is one of the 
projects of PAMCO. This is a joint venture project in collaboration with Mashhad 
Meat Industrial Complex Iran. Salient features of this project are as 
under;
History
History
- 
1999 Lahore Metropolitan Corporation acquired 717 Kanal land at Shahpur Kanjra 18 KM Multan Road Lahore
- 
May 2010, Agreements were signed by Govt of Punjab for technical consultancy & 80:20 % JV with MMIC Iran.
- 
Lahore Meat Company was formed under Section 42, Company Ordinance 1984 in May 2010. The position of MD/CEO was internationally advertised &Dr. Hamid Jalil was selected as CEO in July 2010.
Construction 
process
Planned gestation period ~ 18 months
Completion ~ 12 month
Designing, BOQs, top supervision etc.~ MMIC Iran
Equity of MMIC Iran
Mechanical slaughtering equipment cost ~ Rs.300/-million
Equity of PAMCO Govt. of Punjab
Civil & mechanical works, etc. ~ Rs.1200 million
Total approx. project cost~ Rs.1500 million
Lahore Meat Processing 
Complex ~ Features
- 
Mechanical slaughtering lines & processing system for beef & mutton
- 
Value addition through allied products
- 
Blood Rendering Plant, Meat & Bone Meal Rendering Plant
- 
Waste Water Filtration Plant
- 
Refrigeration & cooling system( Chilling, Blast freezing & Cold storage)
- 
Compliance of standards at all tiers of value chain
- 
Meat technology institute in collaboration with UVAS
- 
Contracted Internationally recognized Certification Body (Bureau Veritas Group)
- 
Contracted internationally recognized firm (CABROP) for e-tagging & traceability at all level
Operations
- 
Capacity: 500 beef & 6000 mutton animals/8hr shift
- 
Two shifts: One municipal & one commercial
- 
Local & export meat supply
- 
More than 2200 fattening farms registered with e-tagging system to ensure traceability system for supply of quality animals
- 
A meat brand, “ TAYBISH” registered
- 
Local Quarantine Certificate issued
- 
NOC awarded by Environment Protection Agency
- 
HACCP, ISO & Halal certification achieved
- 
Saudi Food & Drug Authority inspected ~ approval awaited
- 
Malaysian inspection for approval ~ due in May, 2012
- 
Mauritius approval in process
- 
Approval for Iran awarded
- 
Received demand from five Indian Ocean Islands ~ detailed finalized in consultation with Pak Ambassador & local businessmen
- 
Americana Company (supplier of Hardees Patties to 13 countries) visited & finalized business proposal with LMPC
- 
Malaysian Ambassador together with group of businessmen visited LMPC
- 
Received demand of by-products from Spain, Romania, China, India, etc
OUTSOURCING OPERATION & 
MANAGEMENT OF LMPC
- 
Ready for Project (RFP) package was vetted by the Finance & P&D Department Govt of Punjab.
- 
RFP package was also endorsed by the third party transaction advisor (M/S Ernst & Young).
- 
EOI was advertised in September 2011. Only one applicant was technically pre-qualified in response of 1st advertisement on 15 Oct 2011, which was not accepted on the basis of direct conflict of interest (M/S Polyline Pvt ltd a company owned by a powerful family of Punjab, was part of the bidder consortium).Dispute started from this event.
- 
EOI was re-advertised. In response to 2nd advertisement, four parties submitted their bids; three parties were prequalified.
- 
The RFP Package, agreement and bid documents were finalized by the eight members committee including three Board members.
- 
Out of four bidders one party M/S CoCo Traders & other partners (M/S Dogus Makina Turkish, and MS Martha German) emerged as the final candidatewho submitted financial bid.
- 
The evaluation of bid was carried out by the third party transaction advisor (M/S Ernst & Young).
- 
The bid evaluation report and the process of O&M was thoroughly perused by the Executive Committee, chaired by Secretary Livestock in its first meeting, the committee unanimously endorsed the process and recommended M/S CoCo trader (Pvt) Ltd as a successful bidder for formal approval of Board of Directors.
- 
The same was discussed in the Board on 28th Dec 2011 in its 13th meeting chaired by the Chief Minister Punjab and the, “house endorsed the process of O&M of LMPC and approved the recommendations of Executive Committee to award the contract to M/S CoCo Trader at 16% ROE for 15 years, the house also authorized the CEO/Management to sign the agreement”, thereby the finality of the transaction was achieved.
- 
Offer letter was issued, and contract was signed with M/S CoCo Traders Pvt Ltd (on behalf of three partners, M/S Dogus Turkey, M/S Martha German & M/S COCO Traders Pakistan) on 28th February 2012 after receiving the security amount of Rs.20 million.
- 
To hand over the charge of LMPC to M/S CoCo traders as Licensee before the last prescribed date (1st April 2012), the M/S CoCo Traders was liable to deposit performance security bond for three months revenue (Rs.60m) and to form Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV) of the other Bid partners that is M/S Dogus and M/S Martha German.
- 
Accordingly, M/S CoCo Traders submitted performance bond on March 31, that was proved invalid, furthermore SPV documents were also submitted indicating SPV name ‘Lahore Industrial Meat Complex (Pvt) Limited’ with certificate of incorporation and Form 29.
- 
It was astonishing to note that the said SPV which was supposed to be having composition of successful bidder M/S CoCo Trader and other partners (M/S Dogus and M/S Martha German), instead, a stranger Company, M/S Polyline Pvt ltd (owned by powerful family of Punjab) was present in SPV rather than the original partners (Form 29 of M/S Lahore Industrial Meat Complex Pvt ltd).
- 
This was a gross violation on the part of successful bidder M/S CoCo Traders who was originally pre-qualified on the basis of strength of other partners, M/S Dogus and M/S Martha German;
- 
The PAMCO management decided to take legal action & emergent meeting of executive committee was called on 4th April 2012 to get the approval of cancellation process.
- 
It is worth mentioning here that the same stranger company (M/S Polyline Pvt ltd -owned by the powerful family which is a subsidiary of HY Corporation holding company of Sharif Family----Form A& 29 can be verified from SECP) who emerged as a part of SPV formed by the M/S CoCo Traders was rejected by the PAMCO Management in response to 1st advertisement on the basis of direct clash of interest. The PAMCO management with the support of Executive Committee of BOD issued legal notices to cancel the agreement process of handing over O& M of LMPC to M/S CoCo traders &partner’s consortium.
- 
Consequent upon the legal action completed on April 18th, taken against the COCO Traders/Polyline, the CM Punjab called an emergent meeting of PAMCO BOD on 20th April 9 am, without any formal notice. Only public sector members participate. There was extremely aggressive & hostile attitude against the CEO, however CEO defended the management decisions & rendered his resignation.
- 
The above mentioned sequence of facts is self-explanatory to understand the background of resignation of CEO-PAMCO, who faced tremendous pressure for more than three months to accommodate a company, owned by the powerful family, but ultimately responded to his conscious. Now he is facing serious consequences. His name is placed on ECL & a malicious campaign is launched against him to cover up the facts. He is put under pressure to keep restrain from revealing the truth
- 
--
 WITH BEST WISHES.
 May the Stars carry shine upon you. May the flowers fill your
 heart with beauty. May hope forever wipe away your tears. And
 above all
 Love – Care – N – Smiles
 DR KHALID MAHMOOD SHOUQ (D.V.M) UAF
 https://www.facebook.com/VetNewsViews
 EDITOR IN CHIEF
 THE VETERINARY NEWS & VIEWS [WEEKLY]
 CELL + 92 300 6620616 SMS +92 332 6620616
 SECRETARY
 THE WORLD'S POULTRY SCIENCE ASSOCIATION PAKISTAN BRANCH
 TEL;+92 41 2665352 FAX;+92 41 2562853
 POSTAL;HOUSE;392-A,SAMANABAD FAISLABAD PAKISTAN
 
 
